Kelsay v. Carson, Ky COA, Modification of Custody and Parenting Schedule

Kelsay v. Carson 2009-CA-002175-ME

Kelsay v. Carson 2009-CA-002175-ME

Published:   Affirming

County: Boyle


Father appealed FC’s order making Mother primary residential parent of Child. 



Mother and Father, never married, had Child in 2000.  In 2004, FC entered Order awarding joint custody and designating Father as primary residential custodian.  In 2008, Mother moved FC to change custody, based on Father’s history of alcohol abuse, including 2 DUI’s in previous 18 months.  FC order joint custody to continue, but changed primary residential parent from Father to Mother.  Father appealed.



CA noted that under Pennington v. Marcum, Mother was actually seeking change in parenting time, not a change in custody, and therefore falls under the purview of KRS § 403.320. This statute states that visitation/time-sharing may only be modified upon a proper showing that “modification would serve the best interests of the child.”  FC properly relied on Mother’s evidence that demonstrated that it was “in the best interest of the child” that Mother become the primary residential parent.



Digested by Michelle Eisenmenger Mapes, Diana L. Skaggs + Associates  

Recent Posts

Kentucky Court of Appeals holds Relatives’ Writ of Prohibition is appropriate, stays Jefferson Family Court DNA action pending ruling by Breckinridge Circuit Court on Relative’s private custody and adoption petitions
January 31, 2023
Flowing hourglass on wooden table; Twilight blue
Kentucky Court of Appeals vacates order of Oldham Family Court terminating Husband’s maintenance obligations based on Wife’s cohabitation
December 18, 2022
Kentucky Court of Appeals reverses and remands Jefferson County Family Court’s termination of parental rights due to lack of cited evidence showing termination was clearly and convincingly in the child’s best interest
December 8, 2022