Kentucky Court of Appeals affirms Warren Family Court’s Order limiting natural father’s access to children’s educational records from school

Robert Andrew Sharp v. Robbin Nelson; Heather Anne Sharp; and Warren County Public Schools, Case No. 2021-CA-1005-MR

Natural mother and father went through a divorce proceeding in 2014, and paternal grandmother petitioned for custody of the parties’ two minor children.  The family court granted grandmother’s petition, only to find that grandmother made fraudulent statements at the hearing on her petition (which mother and father were not present for).  Thereafter, a custody battle for the two children ensued, which ultimately resulted in sole custody of the children being awarded to mother. 

The family court also entered an order that grandmother and the minor children were not to have contact.  Grandmother filed numerous complaints against mother to the Cabinet for Health and Family Services (CHFS), causing the family court to be skeptical of both grandmother and father’s motivation in continuously intervening in mother’s parenting and care of the children.  The subject of this action pertained to an incident where father appeared in person at the children’s school and sought information regarding an eye examination of one of the children.  Although the school declined to provide same to father, he claimed one of the nurses told him the results of the test – which he then communicated to paternal grandmother.  Paternal grandmother, on the same day, called the school alleging mother was abusing the children.  The school reported same to CHFS, and paternal grandmother also reported the alleged abuse to CHFS. 

Mother, as a result, filed an emergency motion to cease father’s parenting time with the children, arguing father simply utilized his time with the children to gather information to use against mother in the future.  Following a hearing on mother’s emergency motion, the family court entered an order stating “[father] is not to be involved in decision making regarding the children or to gather information concerning the children,” and father filed a motion to alter, amend, or vacate.  The family court granted his motion, in part, but did not amend its ruling that father could not gather information about the children. 

Shortly after, father demanded extensive information from the children’s school, and Warren County Public Schools (WCPS) filed a motion with the family court as a non-party requesting clarification of the family court’s order prohibiting father from gathering information about the children.  Following a hearing on WCPS’ motion for clarification, the family court entered an order disallowing father from obtaining any school records regarding the children except for school report cards.  Father filed a motion to alter, amend, or vacate the order, or for specific findings of fact be entered to support the order.  The family court denied father’s motion to alter, amend, or vacate; however, it did make additional findings, where it emphasized its concern of father attempting to gather information to give to paternal grandmother for CHFS referrals and ongoing litigation. 

This appeal followed, where father alleged the family court did not properly interpret its earlier order prohibiting him from obtaining school records.  He also alleged the family court erred in finding father continually reported mother to CHFS as a means of harassment.

The Court of Appeals determined the family court’s order appropriately limited father’s ability gather information about the children, and that the order extended to educational records.  Further, the Court found the family court’s order appropriately satisfies the statutory exception for limiting a noncustodial parent’s access to educational records when there is “a court order establishing such ban . . .”[1]  Finally, the Court echoed the frustrations of the family court, noting the record reflected father and paternal grandmother were acting together in making referrals to CHFS.  For those reasons, the Court of Appeals affirmed the Warren County Family Court’s order limiting father’s access to the children’s educational records.

Caitlin P. Kidd, Esq.

[1] Kentucky Revised Statutes (KRS) § 403.330.

Recent Posts

Watch Partner Elizabeth Howell go Over the Edge for Gilda’s Club Kentuckiana!
July 10, 2023
Kentucky Court of Appeals Affirms Fayette Family Court Orders Finding Mother’s Choice in Schools Outside the Residential County to be Unreasonable and Awarding Attorney’s Fees
June 20, 2023
Kentucky Supreme Court Reverses and Remands Order Holding Non-Party Responsible for Attorney’s Fees Due to Non-Compliance with Subpoena
June 20, 2023